Wednesday briefing: FIFA suspends all transfer rule cases impacted by Diarra judgement
Wednesday briefing: FIFA suspends all transfer rule cases impacted by Diarra judgement
IMAGO
Manchester United post £1.4 million profit for Q1 2024/25
Watzke defends Dortmund sponsorship deal with German arms manufacturer
Legal battle ensues over confidentiality agreement between lobbyist and PSG president
27 November 2024 - 4:30 AM
FIFA has announced the suspension of all its ongoing cases related to the transfer rules that have been deemed unlawful by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)’s judgement on the Lassana Diarra case.
The CJEU ruled last month in favour of the former French player, stating that specific FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) conflicted with EU law.
FIFA has now suspended all its cases before its Disciplinary Committee concerning Articles 6 and 17 of the RSTP, both of which were deemed "contrary" to EU law and "likely to hinder the free movement" of professional footballers by the CJEU.
Disciplinary measures
FIFA said it will abandon for the time being "any disciplinary measures" against "players" and "coaches" who have not respected these two rules, meaning they are for now able to leave their club without having to suffer sporting sanctions or pay compensation.
However, FIFA stressed the suspension of the cases does not exclude "a subsequent reinstatement" and does not constitute an "admission of illegality of such measures".
Manchester United post £1.4 million profit for Q1 2024/25
Manchester United have reported a net profit of £1.4 million and operating loss of £6.9 million for the three-month period ending 30th September 2024.
The club acknowledged that the slender net profit, which followed a loss of £25.8 million in the same period last year, was “attributable primarily to foreign exchange gains on unhedged US dollar borrowings”, adding that “the majority of this gain is expected to be reversed” in Q2 2024/25.
Key factors behind the operating loss for the period, which came after an operating profit of £1.9 million in Q1 2023/24, were United's absence from the Champions League this season and costs related to the club’s redundancy programme.
Broadcast revenue fell by 20.4 per cent year-on-year to £31.3 million, while commercial income declined by 5.6 per cent to £85.3 million and matchday revenue was down 3.3 per cent to £26.5 million.
Wage bill falls 11.2 per cent
United's wage bill in Q1 2024/25 was £80.2 million, a fall of 11.2 per cent on the prior year’s first quarter, with the club saying the drop was due "primarily to changes in the make-up of the first-team playing squad".
The Old Trafford club also recorded an exceptional cost of £8.6 million which they said "comprises costs incurred in relation to the restructuring of the group's operations, including the redundancy scheme implemented in the first quarter of financial year 2025".
Watzke defends Dortmund sponsorship deal with German arms manufacturer
Borussia Dortmund CEO Hans-Joachim Watzke has defended the club’s sponsorship deal with Rheinmetall, Germany’s biggest arms manufacturer, despite strong opposition to the agreement from fans.
The controversial three-year partnership, which the Bundesliga club agreed in May, was a key talking point at the club’s AGM on Sunday, with two mock tanks and an information stand set up in protest at the deal.
Members attacked the agreement, with a majority voting in favour of a motion to end the partnership as quickly as possible. Of the 855 members present 556 voted in favour, with 247 voting against and 52 abstaining.
“Balancing act”
However, Watzke stood firm on the deal when addressing the AGM. "It was a decision that involved a balancing act between economic aspects and social sustainability,” he said. “The committees voted unanimously in favour of it. But I have respect for everyone who sees it differently."
Managing director Carsten Cramer added: "The only area we can grow is sponsorship. We have red lines there. We have rejected funds from Russia or those that we believe contradict Borussia Dortmund's CSR criteria."
Legal battle ensues over confidentiality agreement between lobbyist and PSG president
A France-Algerian lobbyist has taken legal action to nullify a confidentiality agreement he signed with Nasser al-Khelaïfi, the Qatari president of Paris Saint-Germain (PSG), claiming he was coerced into the agreement, according to a report from L'Équipe.
The lobbyist, Tayeb Benabderrahmane, argues that the agreement, which required him to hand over any "confidential document" concerning "NAK" (al-Khelaïfi), was signed under duress. He entered the agreement on July 10, 2020.
According to Benabderrahmane's account during a civil hearing at the Paris Judicial Tribunal, he was arrested in Doha in January 2020 and subjected to harsh conditions in a Qatari prison. He alleges that his release from detention was contingent upon signing the agreement, orchestrated by al-Khelaïfi's lawyers and his brother, who was head of Qatari intelligence.
Another perspective
Al-Khelaïfi's camp tells a different story, claiming Benabderrahmane was arrested for espionage and attempting to sell information to the United Arab Emirates. They assert that al-Khelaïfi had no involvement in the arrest and only became aware of it in May. Al-Khelaïfi's lawyer, Marie Burguburu, maintains that the agreement is valid as Benabderrahmane faced no "resistance" during signing and had legal representation.
Furthermore, al-Khelaïfi is demanding €5 million from Benabderrahmane for allegedly violating the protocol by retaining potentially compromising digital content for blackmail purposes.
Benabderrahmane is also under separate criminal investigation for stealing intimate images of al-Khelaïfi. Another investigation into potential torture in Qatari prison is ongoing. The court will deliver its decision on April 29, 2025.