Monday briefing: Diarra case - Europe’s highest court says transfer rules breach EU law
Monday briefing: Diarra case - Europe’s highest court says transfer rules breach EU law
IMAGO
RedBird Capital denies reports of selling AC Milan stake
Lazio report record revenue and strong profits in 2023/24
7 October 2024 - 4:30 AM
FIFA will need to amend parts of its transfer regulations following a European Court of Justice (CJEU) ruling in the case of Lassana Diarra, that could have wider implications depending on future legal interpretations of the judgement.
The ruling requires changes to ensure penalties for players breaking contracts are less severe. While this decision does not have the same immediate impact as the landmark 1995 Bosman ruling, its long-term effects could reshape football’s transfer landscape depending on future court cases.
Diarra’s case stems from his 2014 contract termination with Lokomotiv Moscow. He sought FIFA’s confirmation as a free agent to join Charleroi, but delays led to the Belgian club withdrawing their offer. Diarra argued that this delay amounted to a restraint of trade.
In Diarra's favour
On Friday the CJEU ruled in Diarra’s favour, stating that specific FIFA regulations, particularly article 17.2, conflicted with EU law. This article dictates how compensation is paid when a player terminates their contract without just cause.
The ruling emphasised the need for more balanced contractual relationships between players and clubs, while still recognizing the importance of maintaining contractual stability in football.
FIFA responded by acknowledging the ruling but downplayed its significance, emphasising that only two paragraphs of two articles are affected. Legal experts scrutinising the ruling say it may lead to minor adjustments rather than a complete overhaul, suggesting that FIFA already operates in line with the court’s expectations.
RedBird Capital denies reports of selling AC Milan stake
RedBird Capital, the U.S. investment firm that owns AC Milan, has categorically denied a report from Italian newspaper La Repubblica claiming it is seeking to sell a stake in the club, according to Reuters.
A spokesperson for RedBird stated, "The reporting by La Repubblica about selling a stake in AC Milan is a complete fabrication. It is wholly untrue." The firm acquired AC Milan in 2022 from another U.S. fund, Elliott, in a deal valued at €1.2 billion.
According to La Repubblica, the purchase was partially financed through a vendor loan from Elliott worth €560 million due next year, complemented by RedBird's investment of €681 million. The newspaper suggested that RedBird was looking to "rebalance its portfolio" by offloading up to €150 million of its initial capital investment at base cost.
Doesn't know the investment firm
La Repubblica cited a document allegedly prepared by U.S. investment firm Washington Harbour on behalf of RedBird, which has reportedly been shared in financial circles since May.
However, in an earlier statement to Reuters, a RedBird spokesperson clarified that Gerry Cardinale, the founder and managing partner of RedBird, "does not know Washington Harbour and the document cited by the newspaper is not attributable to him."
Lazio report record revenue and strong profits
Champions League football and player sales helped Lazio achieve the highest turnover in the club’s history and a €40.7 million pre-tax profit in 2023/24.
Turnover reached €195 million, up from €148.6 million in 2022/23. The main growth drivers were broadcast and matchday income, which rose by 40 per cent and 55 per cent respectively, boosted by Champions League participation compared to the Europa League the previous year.
Despite this, the club managed to limit expenses to a 9 per cent increase, partly due to a wage bill that grew by just 5 per cent, resulting in a rare operating profit in European football.
Disappointing season
The sale of Milinković-Savić to Saudi Pro League club Al-Hilal also brought in a €40 million profit from player sales. Lazio ultimately reported a €40.7 million pre-tax profit.
However, a disappointing domestic season, finishing 7th, means Lazio missed out on Champions League football for the 2024/25 season, which will undoubtedly impact the club’s income.